State wins on appeal in long-term immigration detention lawsuit as Tokyo High Court finds no illegality, overturning a 1.2 million yen award
This article organizes publicly available information into a single account. Where it describes an arrest or an ongoing investigation, that reflects only one stage of criminal procedure and does not mean guilt has been established (the presumption of innocence applies). We will update this article as new information becomes available, including the outcome of prosecution, non-prosecution, or trial. This article is not intended to unfairly disparage any individual, group, nationality, ethnicity, or belief, and aims to provide objective, fact-based information.
On September 30, 2026 the Tokyo High Court handed down its appellate judgment in a lawsuit in which two foreign men sought about 30 million yen in total damages from the state, arguing that repeated long-term detention at Immigration Services Agency facilities together with cycles of provisional release and re-detention was unlawful. The court overturned the first-instance judgment and dismissed their claims. Kyodo News distributed the report the same day and it was carried by outlets including the Kumamoto Nichinichi Shimbun.
The plaintiffs, one of whom is named Safari Diman Heidar, had both lost their residence status and been issued deportation orders, and said they were repeatedly detained, released on provisional release and detained again while their refugee applications were pending. The Tokyo District Court had found that at least one of them continued to be held despite deteriorating health and ordered the state to pay 1.2 million yen in total, after which both the state and the plaintiffs appealed. The High Court concluded that the immigration authority had not exceeded its discretion and that its handling was "not recognized as illegal."
Current status: Whether the plaintiffs will appeal to the Supreme Court, the detailed reasoning of the judgment, and the two men's current residence or detention status were not clear as of this writing. This article will be updated as further details emerge.
The government has approved an increase of 226 Immigration Services Agency staff as a measure against overstayers, drawing greater attention to how detention and deportation are administered (related article).
Editorial Perspective
The Technical Intern Training Program is set to be replaced by the new Employment for Skill Development system in April 2027 (related article), and developments like this one can be seen as part of the institutional design process during that transition. Expanding acceptance also requires resolving practical issues such as broker problems in sending countries and building proper oversight systems among accepting employers. For the new system to work as intended rather than merely on paper, it will be important to continue examining how it actually operates once implemented.